Publix vs Walmart: Which is cheaper for Groceries? Quality, Price and Services

Last updated: 19 Dec, 2023 |
Publix vs Walmart Which is cheaper for Groceries Quality Price and Services

As someone deeply immersed in supermarkets and retail for nearly a decade, the clash between Publix and Walmart for the title of ultimate grocery champion is a topic close to my heart.

It’s a debate that resonates in countless cities, where residents choose between Walmart’s promise of value and low prices and Publix’s unwavering commitment to quality and service.

In this comparison, we’ll dissect the intricacies of pricing, deals, and overall value to determine which emerges as the true victor in groceries. So, join me on this journey as we unravel the mysteries of these retail giants and unveil the ultimate shopping destination for you.

Walmart: The Price Leader

Walmart is known for its low prices and good reason. The company has a long history of offering competitive prices on a wide variety of products, from groceries to electronics to home goods. Walmart can keep its prices low by operating on a large scale and negotiating favorable prices with suppliers.

In addition to its low prices, Walmart offers a convenient shopping experience. Walmart stores are typically large and well-stocked, offering various services, such as pharmacies, grocery pick-ups, and money transfers. This makes Walmart a one-stop shop for many consumers.

While Walmart is known for its low prices, it is important to note that the quality of its products can vary. Some Walmart products are of high quality, while others are not. It is important to read reviews and compare prices before purchasing at Walmart.

Overall, Walmart is a good choice for shoppers looking for low prices and a convenient shopping experience. However, it is important to be aware that the quality of Walmart products can vary.

Publix: A Surprising Contender

Publix is a regional grocery chain that is known for its high-quality products and customer service. Publix stores are typically smaller and more upscale than Walmart stores. Publix also offers a wider variety of specialty and gourmet items.

While Publix is generally more expensive than Walmart, a few things set Publix apart from its competitors.

First, Publix offers a wide variety of fresh and organic produce.

Second, Publix has a reputation for excellent customer service.

Third, Publix offers a variety of loyalty programs that can help shoppers save money.

Publix is a good choice for shoppers looking for high-quality products, excellent customer service, and a wide variety of specialty and gourmet items.

However, it is important to know that Publix is generally more expensive than Walmart.

Publix vs Walmart Quality and Cost comparison
Publix vs Walmart Quality and Cost comparison.jpg

Product Quality Comparison

Overall, both Publix and Walmart offer high-quality products. However, Publix is known for its slightly higher quality products and customer service. Some customers may be willing to pay a premium for this.

Here is a more detailed comparison of the product quality in each category:

  • Dairy: Publix offers a wider variety of high-quality dairy products than Walmart. For example, Publix sells more brands of organic milk and cheese. Walmart also offers a variety of high-quality dairy products, but the selection is not as extensive.
  • Produce: Publix offers more fresh and organic produce than Walmart. Walmart also offers a variety of fresh and organic produce, but the selection is not as extensive. Additionally, Publix’s produce is generally of higher quality than Walmart’s produce.
  • Meat and Seafood: Publix offers more high-quality meat and seafood than Walmart. For example, Publix sells more brands of grass-fed beef and wild-caught salmon. Walmart also offers a variety of high-quality meat and seafood, but the selection is not as extensive. Additionally, Publix meat and seafood is generally higher quality than Walmart meat and seafood.
  • Bakery: Publix is known for its high-quality bakery products. Walmart also offers a variety of bakery products, but the quality is not as high as Publix.
  • Deli: Publix is known for its high-quality deli products. Walmart also offers a variety of deli products, but the quality is not as high as Publix.
  • Snacks: Publix offers a wider variety of healthy and organic snacks than Walmart. Walmart also offers a variety of healthy and organic snacks, but the selection is not as extensive.
  • Beverages: Publix offers a wider variety of craft beers and wines than Walmart. Walmart also offers a variety of craft beers and wines, but the selection is not as extensive.
  • Personal care: Publix offers a wider variety of high-end beauty products than Walmart. Walmart also offers a variety of high-end beauty products, but the selection is not as extensive.
  • Household goods: Publix offers a wider variety of high-quality household goods than Walmart. Walmart also offers a variety of high-quality household goods, but the selection is not as extensive.

If we look at the quality factor then the publix is the winner, this might be the reason of their expensive items.

Product CategoryPublixWalmart
DairyHighGood
ProduceHighGood
Meat and SeafoodHighGood
BakeryHighGood
DeliHighGood
SnacksHighGood
BeveragesHighGood
Personal careHighGood
Household goodsHighGood

Walmart vs. Publix: The Price Showdown

produce Items

Here is a more comprehensive list of produce prices from both stores, including more fruits:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PriceCheaper Store
Apples$1.99 per pound$1.58 per poundWalmart
Bananas$0.76 per pound$0.58 per poundWalmart
Blueberries$3.99 per pint$2.98 per pintWalmart
Cantaloupe$2.99 each$1.98 eachWalmart
Carrots$1.43 per pound$0.67 per poundWalmart
Celery$1.29 per bunch$0.98 per bunchWalmart
Cucumber$0.87 each$0.74 eachWalmart
Grapes$2.99 per pound$1.98 per poundWalmart
Green beans$1.99 per pound$1.28 per poundWalmart
Lettuce$3.29 per head$1.98 per headWalmart
Mushrooms$1.99 per pound$1.28 per poundWalmart
Onions$0.69 per pound$0.48 per poundWalmart
Oranges$1.49 per pound$0.98 per poundWalmart
Pears$1.99 per pound$1.58 per poundWalmart
Pineapple$2.99 each$1.98 eachWalmart
Potatoes$6.09 for a 5-pound bag$3.67 for a 5-pound bagWalmart
Strawberries$3.99 per pint$2.98 per pintWalmart
Tomatoes$0.99 each on sale$2.18 per poundPublix

As you can see, Walmart is cheaper than Publix for most produce items. The only exception is tomatoes, which are on sale at Publix for $0.99 each.

deli and meat

Here is a more comprehensive list of deli and meat prices from both stores, including more products:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PriceCheaper Store
Bacon (pre-cooked, 2.1 oz)$5.19$3.78Walmart
Chicken (whole, 5.89 lbs)$9.72 on sale$8.08Walmart
Ground turkey (1 lb, 93%)$5.19$3.58Walmart
Hamburger patties (1 lb, 85/15)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Hot dogs (1 lb, all-beef)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Italian sausage (1 lb, sweet or hot)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Pork chops (bone-in, 1.49 lbs)$6.09 per lb$3.68 per lbWalmart
Ribeye steaks (1 lb, boneless)$12.99$9.98Walmart
Salmon fillets (1 lb, Atlantic)$10.99$7.98Walmart
Shrimp (1 lb, jumbo)$11.99$8.98Walmart

As you can see, Walmart is generally more affordable for deli and meat products than Publix. The only exception is boneless ribeye steaks, which are slightly cheaper at Publix.

frozen food

Here is a more comprehensive list of frozen food prices from both stores, including more products:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PriceCheaper Store
Frozen mixed vegetables (15 oz bag)$2.53$0.84Walmart
Frozen peas (15 oz bag)$2.53$0.84Walmart
Frozen broccoli (12 oz bag)$1.99$1.18Walmart
Frozen corn (12 oz bag)$1.99$1.18Walmart
Frozen french fries (32 oz bag)$2.99$1.98Walmart
Frozen pizza (12 inch)$3.99$2.98Walmart
Frozen chicken nuggets (16 oz bag)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Frozen hamburger patties (1 lb)$4.99$3.98Walmart

As you can see, Walmart is generally more affordable for frozen foods than Publix.

DAIRY ITEMS

Here is a more comprehensive list of dairy prices from both stores, including more products:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PriceCheaper Store
Eggs (Publix Large Eggs 12ct)$3.09$2.15Walmart
Sour cream (Publix 8oz tub)$1.53$1.16Walmart
Shredded cheddar cheese (Publix 8oz bag)$4.29$2.22Walmart
Shredded mozzarella cheese (Publix 8oz bag)$4.29$2.22Walmart
Butter (sticks) (Publix 8oz)$3.43$3.98Walmart
Milk (2% gallon)$5.49$4.38Walmart
Cottage cheese (16oz)$2.49$1.98Walmart
Greek yogurt (16oz)$2.99$2.48Walmart
Shredded Parmesan cheese (8oz bag)$3.99$2.98Walmart
Yogurt tubes (4-pack)$2.49$1.98Walmart
Cream cheese (8oz)$2.99$2.48Walmart
Half and half (1/2 gallon)$3.99$3.48Walmart

It is also worth noting that Publix may offer a wider variety of produce and dairy products than Walmart, especially in specialty and gourmet items. Some customers may be willing to pay a premium for this selection.

DRY GOODS

Here is a more comprehensive list of dry goods prices from both stores, including more products:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PricePrice RangeCheaper Store
Flour$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Sugar$1.49$1.29LowWalmart
Salt$0.99$0.79LowWalmart
Baking powder$0.99$0.79LowWalmart
Baking soda$0.99$0.79LowWalmart
Spices$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Herbs$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Pasta$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Rice$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Cereal$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Granola$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Snacks$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Coffee$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Tea$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Hot chocolate$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Juice$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Soda$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Water$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Peanut butter (Jif 16oz jar)$3.39$2.16 on saleMediumWalmart
Sandwich bread (20oz)$2.43$1.00LowWalmart
Maple syrup (24oz bottle)$3.53$2.14MediumWalmart
Oatmeal (18oz container)$3.87$1.76MediumWalmart
Brown sugar (16oz)$1.65$1.62LowWalmart
Mayonnaise (Duke’s 8oz)$3.09$2.80MediumWalmart
Raisins (12oz box)$3.19$2.58MediumWalmart
Black beans (dried)$1.75$0.92LowWalmart
Lentils (dry)$1.35$1.18LowWalmart
Canned tomatoes (x2)$1.68 on sale$1.44LowWalmart
BBQ sauce (18oz bottle)$2.53$1.12LowWalmart
Alfredo sauce (15oz jar)$3.49$1.50MediumWalmart
Brown rice (16oz bag)$1.31$1.37LowWalmart
Taco seasoning (1.5oz pack)$1.05$0.48LowWalmart
Tortillas (Mission Street 12ct)$2.53$1.98MediumWalmart
Kidney beans (15.5oz can)$1.09$0.72LowWalmart
Chili powder (Badia Spices 2.5oz jar)$2.37$0.98LowWalmart
Cornbread mix (Jiffy Mix 8.5oz box)$0.71$0.47LowWalmart
Popcorn (Pop Secret 7.8oz 3ct)$4.09$1.33HighWalmart

As you can see, Walmart is generally cheaper for dry goods than Publix. However, a few exceptions exist, such as popcorn, which is cheaper at Publix on sale.

FROZEN FOOD

Here is a more comprehensive list of frozen food prices from both stores, including more frozen goods:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PriceCheaper Store
Frozen mixed vegetables (15oz bag)$2.53$0.84Walmart
Frozen peas (15oz bag)$2.53$0.84Walmart
Frozen broccoli (12oz bag)$1.99$1.18Walmart
Frozen corn (12oz bag)$1.99$1.18Walmart
Frozen french fries (32oz bag)$2.99$1.98Walmart
Frozen pizza (12 inch)$3.99$2.98Walmart
Frozen chicken nuggets (16oz bag)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Frozen hamburger patties (1lb)$4.99$3.98Walmart
Frozen lasagna (14oz)$3.99$2.98Walmart
Frozen waffles (10ct)$2.49$1.98Walmart
Frozen ice cream (pint)$2.99$1.98Walmart
Frozen yogurt (pint)$2.99$1.98Walmart

Here is a table of some of the items in these categories, with the price range and cheaper store indicated:

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PricePrice RangeCheaper Store
Ground beef (1lb)$4.99$3.98LowWalmart
Chicken breast (1lb)$5.99$4.98LowWalmart
Salmon fillet (1lb)$10.99$7.98MediumWalmart
Apples$1.99$1.58LowWalmart
Bananas$0.76$0.58LowWalmart
Broccoli$1.99$1.18LowWalmart
Bread (20oz)$2.43$1.00LowWalmart
Milk (2% gallon)$5.49$4.38LowWalmart
Eggs (12ct)$3.09$2.15MediumWalmart
Cheese (8oz bag)$4.29$2.22MediumWalmart
Snacks (10ct bag)$2.99$1.98MediumWalmart
Soda (12-pack)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart
Shampoo (20oz bottle)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart
Toilet paper (12-pack)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart

BAKERY AND HOUSEHOLD GOODS

bakery and household goods prices from Publix and Walmart

ItemPublix PriceWalmart PricePrice RangeCheaper Store
Bread (20oz)$2.43$1.00LowWalmart
Eggs (12ct)$3.09$2.15MediumWalmart
Cheese (8oz bag)$4.29$2.22MediumWalmart
Cookies (12ct package)$2.99$1.98MediumWalmart
Cake (10 inch)$12.99$9.98MediumWalmart
Paper towels (12-pack)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart
Toilet paper (12-pack)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart
Laundry detergent (64oz bottle)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart
Dish soap (24oz bottle)$1.99$1.49LowWalmart
Trash bags (50-pack)$3.99$2.98MediumWalmart

As you can see, Walmart is generally cheaper for bakery and household goods than Publix. However, a few exceptions exist, such as cookies, which are cheaper at Publix on sale.

From all the table comparisons, we have come across that with price, Walmart is a winner, but for the quality, as described above, Publix is the winner.

Why Publix is more expensive than Walmart: Factors

There are a number of factors that contribute to Publix being more expensive than Walmart. Some of these factors include:

  • Higher quality products: Publix is known for its high-quality products, especially in the areas of produce, meat, and seafood. Publix sources its products from a variety of suppliers, including local farmers and ranchers. This allows Publix to offer a wider variety of fresh and high-quality products. However, it also means that Publix’s costs are higher.
  • Better customer service: Publix is also known for its excellent customer service. Publix employees are typically well-trained and friendly. They are also known for going the extra mile to help customers. This high level of customer service comes at a cost, which is reflected in Publix’s prices.
  • More convenient locations: Publix stores are typically located in more convenient locations than Walmart stores. Publix stores are often located in densely populated areas, while Walmart stores are often located on the outskirts of town. This convenience comes at a cost reflected in Publix’s prices.
  • Smaller stores: Publix stores are typically smaller than Walmart stores. This means that Publix has to pay more for rent and utilities per square foot. This increased overhead cost is reflected in Publix’s prices.

Why Walmart is cheaper than Publix: Possible reasons

Walmart can offer lower prices than Publix for a number of reasons, including:

  • Economies of scale: Walmart is the largest retailer in the world. This gives Walmart significant economies of scale, which allows it to negotiate lower prices from suppliers.
  • Focus on low prices: Walmart is known for its focus on low prices. This is one of the company’s core values, reflected in everything Walmart does. Walmart constantly looks for ways to reduce its costs and pass those savings on to customers.
  • Private label brands: Walmart sells a variety of private label brands, which are typically less expensive than national brands. Walmart can charge less for private label brands because it does not have to pay for marketing and advertising costs.
  • Fewer services: Walmart offers fewer services than Publix. For example, Walmart does not have a full-service deli or bakery. This allows Walmart to keep its costs down and pass those savings on to customers.

Overall, Walmart is able to offer lower prices than Publix by focusing on economies of scale, low prices, private label brands, and fewer services.

Safely maximizing savings at Walmart.

  • Shop smart. Make a shopping list and stick to it. This will help you avoid impulse purchases and save money.
  • Compare prices. Use the Walmart app or website to compare different brands and sizes prices. You can also use Walmart’s price match policy to get a lower price if you find the same item cheaper at a competitor.
  • Use coupons and discounts. Walmart offers a variety of coupons and discounts, both online and in-store. Be sure to check the Walmart app or website for the latest deals.
  • Consider Walmart’s private label brands. Walmart’s private label brands are often just as good as national brands but are typically less expensive.
  • Shop during off-peak hours. Walmart is typically busiest on weekends and holidays. If you can, shop during off-peak hours to avoid the crowds and get the best deals.

Local Alternatives

Local alternatives to Walmart and Publix vary depending on your location. However, some common options include:

  • Discount grocery stores: Aldi, Lidl, and Save-A-Lot are all discount grocery stores that offer lower prices than Walmart and Publix on many items.
  • Ethnic grocery stores: Ethnic grocery stores often offer lower prices on fresh produce and specialty items than Walmart and Publix. Some examples include Asian markets, Hispanic markets, and Middle Eastern markets.
  • Farmers markets: Farmers markets offer a great way to buy fresh, local produce at competitive prices.
  • Food cooperatives: Food cooperatives are member-owned grocery stores that often offer lower prices and a wider variety of products than Walmart and Publix.
  • Online grocery delivery services: Online grocery delivery services like Instacart and Shipt can be a convenient way to shop for groceries, but they can also be more expensive than traditional grocery stores.

It is important to compare prices and selection between different stores before you shop to find the best deals. You may also want to consider the convenience of each store when making your decision.

Final Words

Walmart is generally cheaper than Publix due to its economies of scale, focus on low prices, private label brands, and fewer services. Walmart also offers a variety of ways to save money, such as clearance racks, coupons, and Walmart+.

To maximize your savings at Walmart, make a shopping list, compare prices, use coupons and discounts, consider private label brands, and shop during off-peak hours.

See also:  5 Simple Steps to Cancel Walmart Delivery Subscription.

Winner: Walmart

FAQs: Walmart Vs Publix? Which one is cheaper

What is better Publix or Walmart?

Both Publix and Walmart are popular grocery stores with their own strengths and weaknesses.

Publix is known for its:

  • High-quality products
  • Excellent customer service
  • Wide variety of specialty and gourmet items
  • Convenient locations

However, Publix is also generally more expensive than Walmart.

Walmart is known for its:

  • Low prices
  • Convenient locations
  • Wide variety of products
  • Walmart+ membership benefits

However, Walmart products can be of varying quality, and the customer service can be lacking at times.

Ultimately, the best store for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences. If you are looking for the lowest prices, Walmart is the better choice. If you are looking for high-quality products and excellent customer service, Publix is the better choice.

Is Publix an expensive grocery store?

Yes, Publix is generally more expensive than Walmart. However, Publix is known for its high-quality products and excellent customer service. Some customers may be willing to pay a premium for this.

Is Walmart really cheaper for groceries?

Yes, Walmart is generally cheaper for groceries than Publix. Walmart is able to offer lower prices by focusing on economies of scale, low prices, private label brands, and fewer services.

Is there anything cheaper than Walmart?

Yes, there are a few things that are cheaper than Walmart. For example, some discount grocery stores, such as Aldi and Lidl, offer lower prices than Walmart on certain items. Additionally, some farmers markets and ethnic grocery stores may offer lower prices on fresh produce and specialty items.

Recommended

Is Overnight Parking Allowed at Walmart?

I've traveled the country in my trusty RV, using Walmart parking lots as a resting place many times. Walmart is known for its friendly policy towards overnight parking. Many of their locations in the United States and Canada allow travelers, especially those in RVs,...

What is Walmart’s General Return Policy? [Updated]

Walmart makes returning items easy. You can return most in-store or online items within 90 days of purchase. This gives you plenty of time to decide if you're happy with your purchase. Please remember to return items in their original packaging and condition and to...

Does Walmart Accept American Express for In-Store Purchases?

Yes, Walmart accepts American Express for in-store purchases. You can use your American Express card to pay for groceries, electronics, clothing, or any other items available at Walmart. This acceptance extends to all Walmart stores, making it convenient for American...

Does Walmart Do Price Match? [Updated]

Walmart's price-matching policy is designed to ensure that customers get the best possible price on their purchases. This policy allows customers to request a price match if they find an identical item being sold at a lower price by a qualifying competitor. The policy...

Is Walmart Open on July 4th, 2024?

As Independence Day approaches, many people start planning their celebrations, which often include last-minute shopping for party supplies, food, and decorations. One of the most frequently asked questions is, "Is Walmart open on July 4th?" The answer is yes. Walmart...

Does Walmart Take Passport Photos?

Navigating the passport application process can be tricky. As a travel enthusiast who loves to share tips, I know how important it is to get your passport photos right. Let's talk about Walmart's passport photo services to help you have a smooth experience. Does...

Faisal Mian

With a decade of experience as a manager, advisor, and marketer in the retail and consumer service sector, I understand the intricacies of the shopping landscape. I’m committed to delivering valuable insights to enhance your shopping endeavors.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This